Woody and the three Gs (George, Gordon, and Gary)

Blog photos1
Clockwise from top left: Woody Allen, George Gershwin, Gordon Willis on the job, and Gary Graffman. Interestingly, each was born in a different borough of NYC: Allen in the Bronx, Gershwin in Brooklyn, Willis in Queens, and Graffman in Manhattan.

Earlier this week I watched a terrific documentary about Woody Allen. It included a clip I hadn’t seen in years and years, and seeing it three days ago thrilled me as much as it did when I saw it for the first time 34 years ago.  I’m referring to the opening sequence of “Manhattan”: a series of shots of New York City captured in wide-screen black and white by the great cinematographer Gordon Willis, spooling out to the strains of George Gershwin’s “Rhapsody In Blue” played by pianist Gary Graffman and the New York Philharmonic under the baton of Zubin Mehta.

The Daily News front page on Oct. 30, 1975, after President Ford said that he would not approve federal help for the city.
The Daily News front page on Oct. 30, 1975, after President Ford said that he would not approve federal help for the city.

The movie was released during the spring of 1979, when the city was not that far removed from the fiscal crises of the mid-1970’s.  (Anyone else remember this infamous front page from The Daily News?)

It’s been easy to forget during the high-flying days of Mayors Giuliani and Bloomberg, but NYC was a pretty gritty place in the seventies; the crime rate was high and Times Square–filled with prostitutes, XXX-rated movie theaters and drug dealers–was a long way off from its present-day Disneyfied incarnation. It was the city that made Robert DeNiro’s Travis Bickle, in Taxi Driver, snap.

But Woody Allen saw something else. In his book Celluloid Skyline: New York and the Movies, James Sanders writes, “In the broadest terms, the [opening] sequence was a timely reminder–for New Yorkers no less than those who lived elsewhere–that for all its troubles the city still possessed an urban character of unmatched power, well worth fighting for.  But the film also left no doubt that the most precious parts of that urbanism–at least in Woody Allen’s eyes–were those of the past.”

At one point, Allen’s character in the movie, Isaac, delivers these lines: “This is really a great city.  I don’t care what anybody says.  It’s a knockout.”

I couldn’t agree more.

Miscellany: Gary Graffman’s recording of “Rhapsody in Blue” with the NY Philharmonic has always been my favorite, probably because it was the first one with which I became familiar.  (The downside of the movie’s opening sequence, of course, is that it offers an abbreviated performance, only 3+ minutes, down from its full 16+ minute length).  In 1979, Graffman’s performing career was curtailed by an injury to his right hand.  Indeed, his performance heard on the “Manhattan” soundtrack is one of the last times he was able to play with both hands.  Since that time, his performances have been limited to the small repertoire written exclusively for the left hand.  He turned 85 last month and continues to teach at the Curtis Institute of Music in Philadelphia.


  • “Manhattan” has received a little media boost recently as Mariel Hemingway talked about her family history of depression/suicide and how she’s managed to stay so healthy and fit as she approaches her 52nd birthday this month. I love her definition of love near the end of the movie.


    • Yes, there was an interesting piece about her–and some of her healthy lifestyle routines–in the Times Magazine last weekend.


  • Mariel Hemingway almost 52? Impossible! Who stole those decades?

    It is a terrific opening; even the entry of the fireworks is thrilling rather than cliched.

    Re: Miscellany (additional)
    There is a brilliant M*A*S*H episode from a later series where Winchester is attempting to support a young pianist/soldier whose right hand has been damaged irreparably. He sends to Seoul for pieces for the left hand.


    • I hadn’t remembered that M*A*S*H episode! And apparently there is quite a repertory for the left hand (even more than there was during the Korean conflict….)


  • Interesting how the first experience of Rhapsody in Blue is often the one that serves as the basis for comparison. Same is true for me, when I bought an LP back in 1959 with Julius Katchen playing both it and Concerto in F. I still have it in my collection. But the combination of the music and film that introduce “Manhattan” is astounding because of the synergy between both art forms.


Submit a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s